IndiaCalc Hub

Gold Investment in India: Physical Gold vs Gold ETF vs Sovereign Gold Bonds

Vikram Mehta • • 9 min
Gold Investment in India: Physical Gold vs Gold ETF vs Sovereign Gold Bonds

Gold has been integral to Indian culture and investment portfolios for generations. But with multiple options available today, which is the smartest way to invest in gold?

Why Indians Love Gold

Cultural Significance:

  • Weddings and festivals
  • Symbol of prosperity
  • Family heirloom

Investment Benefits:

  • Hedge against inflation
  • Safe haven during market crashes
  • Portfolio diversification
  • No counterparty risk

Historical Returns:
Gold has given 9-10% annual returns over last 20 years in India.

All Gold Investment Options

1. Physical Gold (Jewelry, Coins, Bars)

2. Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGB)

3. Gold ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds)

4. Gold Mutual Funds

5. Digital Gold

Let's compare each in detail.

Physical Gold

Types:

  • Jewelry: 18K, 22K, 24K
  • Coins: From banks, certified dealers
  • Bars: 10g, 50g, 100g

Costs Involved:

Making Charges:

  • Jewelry: 8-25% (₹8,000-25,000 per 10g)
  • Coins: 3-10%
  • Bars: 1-3%

GST: 3% on gold + making charges

Example:
10g gold at ₹60,000/10g
Making charges: 15% = ₹9,000
Subtotal: ₹69,000
GST 3%: ₹2,070
Total: ₹71,070

Selling Costs:

  • Jewelry: Get only metal value (lose making charges!)
  • Coins/Bars: 3-5% discount from market price

Storage:

  • Bank locker: ₹3,000-10,000/year
  • Home safe
  • Risk of theft

Pros:

  • Tangible asset
  • No demat account needed
  • Emergency liquidity (local jeweler)
  • Cultural/emotional value

Cons:

  • High making charges (loss on jewelry)
  • GST 3%
  • Storage and insurance costs
  • Purity concerns
  • No returns during holding

Best For:

  • Wedding/festival needs
  • Emotional/cultural value
  • Prefer tangible assets

Not Ideal For:

  • Pure investment (high costs eat returns)

Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGB)

Issued by: Government of India (RBI)

How it Works:

  • Buy bonds worth gold (₹10,000 buys ~1.67g at ₹6,000/g)
  • Bonds held in demat form
  • Maturity: 8 years (can exit after 5 years)
  • Can sell on stock exchange anytime

Pricing:

  • Issued at current gold price
  • No making charges
  • No GST

Returns:

1. Price Appreciation:
Value moves with gold prices.

2. Interest Income:
2.5% per annum on initial investment (paid semi-annually)

Example:
Buy 10g SGB at ₹60,000/10g
Investment: ₹60,000
Annual interest: ₹1,500 (2.5%)

After 8 years, if gold price ₹1,00,000/10g:
Sale value: ₹1,00,000
Total interest received: ₹12,000
Total return: ₹1,12,000
Effective return: 9.4% p.a.

Use our Gold Investment Calculator to calculate returns.

Taxation:

Interest Income:
Taxable at your slab rate.

Capital Gains:

  • If held till maturity (8 years): Completely tax-free!
  • If sold before maturity: LTCG 12.5% (after 3 years)

Pros:

  • Lowest cost (no making charges, no GST)
  • Extra 2.5% annual interest
  • Tax-free capital gains at maturity
  • No storage needed
  • Can be used as collateral for loans

Cons:

  • 8-year lock-in (though can sell on exchange after 5 years)
  • Issued in limited tranches (6-8 per year)
  • Need demat account
  • Not physically available for emergencies

Best For:

  • Long-term gold investment (5+ years)
  • Investors wanting returns + safety
  • Tax-efficient gold exposure

Gold ETFs

What it is:
Exchange Traded Fund that holds physical gold. 1 unit = 1 gram of gold (approximately).

How to Invest:

  • Buy/sell on stock exchange like shares
  • Need demat + trading account
  • Minimum: 1 unit (₹6,000 at ₹60,000/10g)

Costs:

Expense Ratio: 0.5-1% per year

Brokerage: Same as shares (₹0-20 per trade)

No:

  • Making charges
  • GST on gold (only on expense ratio)
  • Storage cost

Returns:

Track gold price exactly (minus expense ratio).

Example:
Buy 10 units (10g gold equivalent) at ₹60,000
After 1 year, gold at ₹66,000
Your investment: ₹66,000 - 0.5% expense ratio
Value: ₹65,670

Taxation:

  • LTCG (>3 years): 12.5%
  • STCG (<3 years): At slab rate

Pros:

  • High liquidity (sell anytime)
  • Low cost (0.5-1% expense ratio)
  • Can buy small quantities (1g)
  • Demat form (no storage)
  • Transparent pricing

Cons:

  • Need demat account
  • Annual expense ratio
  • No extra interest like SGB
  • Capital gains taxable (not tax-free like SGB)

Best For:

  • Short to medium-term investment
  • Frequent traders
  • Want flexibility to exit anytime

Popular Gold ETFs:

  • SBI Gold ETF
  • HDFC Gold ETF
  • ICICI Prudential Gold ETF
  • Nippon India Gold ETF

Gold Mutual Funds

What it is:
Mutual fund that invests in Gold ETFs.

Difference from Gold ETF:

Gold ETF:

  • Buy on stock exchange
  • Need demat account
  • Lumpsum only

Gold MF:

  • Buy from AMC directly
  • No demat needed
  • SIP option available!

Costs:

Expense Ratio: 0.8-1.2% per year (slightly higher than ETF)

Unique Benefit: SIP in Gold!

Example:
₹2,000 SIP in gold mutual fund for 10 years
Total invested: ₹2.4 lakh
If gold grows at 8% p.a.: ₹3.65 lakh

Taxation:

Same as Gold ETF:

  • LTCG (>3 years): 12.5%
  • STCG (<3 years): Slab rate

Pros:

  • SIP facility
  • No demat needed
  • Professionally managed
  • Easy to buy/sell

Cons:

  • Slightly higher expense ratio than ETF
  • Returns same as gold (no extra interest)

Best For:

  • Want to do SIP in gold
  • Don't have demat account
  • Prefer mutual fund route

Digital Gold

Platforms: Paytm, PhonePe, Google Pay, Tanishq, SafeGold

How it Works:

  • Buy gold online (minimum ₹1)
  • Stored in vault by partner company
  • Can convert to physical gold (coins/jewelry)

Costs:

  • Buying: 2.5-3% over market price
  • Selling: 2.5-3% below market price
  • Total spread: 5-6%!
  • Storage: Usually free

Example:

Gold price: ₹6,000/g
You pay: ₹6,180/g (3% markup)
Sell after 1 year at same gold price
You get: ₹5,820/g (3% markdown)
Loss: 6% even if gold price unchanged!

Pros:

  • Start with ₹1
  • No demat needed
  • Convert to physical gold
  • Easy to buy

Cons:

  • High spread (5-6%)
  • Unclear taxation
  • Counterparty risk
  • Exit charges

Best For:

  • Absolute beginners
  • Micro-savings (₹100/month)
  • Want option to convert to jewelry

Not Ideal For:

  • Serious investment (high costs)

Detailed Comparison Table

Feature Physical Gold SGB Gold ETF Gold MF Digital Gold
Minimum ₹60,000 (10g) ₹5,000 ₹6,000 (1g) ₹1,000 ₹1
Making Cost 8-25% 0% 0% 0% 0%
GST 3% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Expense Ratio 0% 0% 0.5-1% 0.8-1.2% 5-6% spread
Returns Gold price Gold + 2.5% Gold price Gold price Gold price
Taxation 12.5% LTCG Tax-free (8yr) 12.5% LTCG 12.5% LTCG Unclear
Liquidity Moderate Low (5-8 yrs) High High High
Storage Locker needed Demat Demat No demat Digital
SIP Option No No No Yes Yes

How Much Gold in Portfolio?

Traditional Guideline:

  • Aggressive (20s-30s): 5-10% gold
  • Moderate (40s): 10-15% gold
  • Conservative (50+): 15-20% gold

Example Portfolio (₹10L):

  • Equity: 60% (₹6L)
  • Debt: 25% (₹2.5L)
  • Gold: 15% (₹1.5L) via SGB or Gold ETF

Purpose: Diversification + hedge against market crash.

Best Strategy for Different Goals

Goal: Long-Term Wealth (10+ years)

Best: Sovereign Gold Bonds
Why: 2.5% interest + tax-free gains

Goal: Medium-Term (3-5 years)

Best: Gold ETF
Why: Low cost, high liquidity

Goal: Regular Gold Accumulation

Best: Gold Mutual Fund SIP
Why: ₹1,000-5,000 monthly SIP possible

Goal: Wedding/Festival

Best: Save in SGB, convert to jewelry
Why: Accumulate tax-free, buy jewelry when needed

Goal: Micro-Savings (₹100/month)

Best: Digital Gold
Why: Can start with ₹1, though costs are high

Goal: Emergency Fund

Not Recommended: Gold has volatility. Use liquid funds instead.

Tax Implications Summary

Physical Gold:

  • LTCG 12.5% (held >3 years)
  • STCG at slab rate (<3 years)

SGB:

  • Maturity (8 years): Tax-free capital gains!
  • Interest: Taxable at slab rate
  • Early sale: LTCG 12.5%

Gold ETF/MF:

  • LTCG 12.5% (>3 years)
  • STCG at slab rate

Digital Gold:

  • Taxation unclear (varies by platform)

Tax Winner: SGB (tax-free at maturity)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Buying Jewelry as Investment

Making charges 15% = Immediate 15% loss!

Mistake 2: Not Diversifying Gold Investments

Don't put all gold money in one option. Mix SGB + ETF.

Mistake 3: Timing Gold Purchase

Gold prices fluctuate. Use SIP approach in gold mutual funds.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Costs

Physical gold: Making + GST = 10-28% extra cost!

Mistake 5: Over-Allocating to Gold

Gold is diversifier, not growth asset. Max 15-20% of portfolio.

Conclusion

Winner for Investment: Sovereign Gold Bonds

  • Lowest cost
  • Extra 2.5% interest
  • Tax-free capital gains
  • Government-backed

Runner-Up: Gold ETF

  • If you want liquidity
  • Can exit anytime
  • Low cost

For SIP: Gold Mutual Fund

  • Only option for systematic gold accumulation

Physical Gold: Reserve for cultural needs (weddings, festivals), not pure investment.

Digital Gold: Convenience for micro-savings, but high costs.

Recommended Strategy:

  • 70% in SGB (hold 8 years)
  • 30% in Gold ETF (for liquidity)
  • Use gold mutual fund SIP if want to accumulate monthly

Use our Gold Calculator to plan your gold investments.

Gold is a hedge and diversifier, not a growth asset. Allocate wisely within a balanced portfolio.

← Back to all articles